It’s not an easy task, but it can be extremely rewarding. If left unchecked, the atmosphere may begin to feel combative. You can express your strong disagreement or discomfort with such remarks and leave it at that, or follow up with “Let’s talk about it after the group,” which could generate some real discussion about prejudice and stereotypes, and actually change some thinking over time. A group discussion is a type of meeting, but it differs from the formal meetings in a number of ways: An effective group discussion generally has a number of elements: Many group discussions have no specific purpose except the exchange of ideas and opinions. (The exceptions are opinions or ideas that are discriminatory or downright false.) Most of the time, however, it is wiser to stick to the schedule. As a leader, to lead a group discussion, you have great influence over the mood of the room. If minutes are required for your discussion, it is your responsibility as the leader to ensure they are recorded. Discussion groups are an important part of an effective youth ministry program, camp or retreat. Resolve problems with the environment as they occur. Summarizing is important to remind your group of the consensus that has been achieved. Read our permissions policy, privacy policy, or disclosure policy. Act decisively. Responses given in a focus group are verbal, open-ended, relatively broad and qualitative. If you’re asked your opinion directly, you should answer honestly. Become familiar with the purpose and content of the discussion. As explained in the opening paragraphs of this section, group discussions are common in a democratic society. The moments when you summarize verbally are excellent opportunities to clearly document decisions you have reached. and reinvent the way you work. Lead a Group That Matters. She has to prepare the space and the setting to the extent possible; help the group establish ground rules that will keep it moving civilly and comfortably; provide whatever materials are necessary; familiarize herself with the topic; and make sure that any pre-discussion readings or assignments get to participants in plenty of time. Then she has to guide the discussion, being careful to promote an open process; involve everyone and let no one dominate; attend to the personal issues and needs of individual group members when they affect the group; summarize or clarify when appropriate; ask questions to keep the discussion moving, and put aside her own agenda, ego, and biases. to remain available. If those are brought out in the open and discussed reasonably, the two sides often find that they have as much agreement as disagreement, and can resolve their differences by putting their ideas together. If the situation is particularly difficult, a directive leader might be needed to keep control of the discussion and make. There may be situations where it makes sense for someone else to lead the discussion for a certain topic within your overall session. Air concerns and differences among individuals or groups. All Rights Reserved. It's your turn to moderate/lead your book club's discussion. Image credit: Group discussion by Shelley Mannion (CC BY-NC 2.0). Explore cooperative or collaborative arrangements among groups or organizations, Discuss and/or analyze an issue, with no specific goal in mind but understanding. Identify a way to enter a Group Discussion, as every GD has its highs and lows. One of the aims of group discussion should be to get beneath the surface of peoples’ lives. It’s important to think about what you’re most comfortable with philosophically, and how that fits what you’re comfortable with personally. Leading an effective group discussion takes preparation (if you have the opportunity for it), an understanding of and commitment to an open process, and a willingness to let go of your ego and biases. It’s less formal, and may have no time constraints, or structured order, or agenda. Facilitating Political Discussions from the Institute for Democracy and Higher Education at Tufts University is designed to assist experienced facilitators in training others to facilitate politically charged conversations. Ask that God would lead the discussion where he wants it to go. Even where that’s not the case, facing the conflict reasonably, and looking at the roots of the ideas on each side, can help to focus on the issue at hand and provide solutions far better than if one side or the other simply operated alone. Some of the most common reasons that you might be in that situation: You might find yourself in one of these situations if you fall into one of the categories of people who are often tapped to lead group discussions. Some of the most memorable group meetings occur when the leader is willing to scrap the plan for the night and address a specific need, or do something fun and spontaneous. Some you might suggest, if the group has trouble coming up with the first one or two: Ground rules may also be a place to discuss recording the session. Everyday-Democracy. Assume participants all have the same expectations when the group first convenes. A good group discussion leader has to pay attention to the process and content of the discussion as well as to the people who make up the group. Johnson, D., & Frank P. (2002). Feedback could be positive, negative, or merely clarifying or correcting factual questions or errors, but is in all cases delivered respectfully. Use tools which promote discussion. There is no clear-cut answer, although if they pass unchallenged, it may appear you condone the attitude expressed. A college class in human services approaches the topic of dealing with reluctant participants. Let’s look at these, as well as some do’s and don’t’s for discussion group leaders. What Does Your Personal Brand Say About You as a Speaker. 1. 1. Ask questions sincerely. The first thing you need to think about is leadership style, which we mentioned briefly earlier in the section. Even in that situation, the individual may find herself swayed by others’ arguments, or may have ideas of her own. It won’t hurt to think beforehand about how you want to handle it. 1. The group has a trained leader, or facilitator. thirty minutes or an hour), it is sufficient to summarize only at the end. You might choose to lead a group discussion, or you might find yourself drafted for the task. Your contribution can help change lives. This category could include anyone from “professional” community organizers to average citizens who care about an issue or have an idea they want to pursue. It may not have a specific goal – many group discussions are just that: a group kicking around ideas on a particular topic. (I try to do this at least every 60 or 90 minutes.) Be convincing – You can also convince the other participants to get back in the discussion. If there are new members, make sure they are introduced. In a lengthy session (e.g. First, we encourage you to pray. A focus group is different in three basic ways: The main difference is the group has a specific, focused discussion topic. An effective discussion group depends on a leader or facilitator who can guide it through an open process – the group chooses what it’s discussing, if not already determined, discusses it with no expectation of particular conclusions, encourages civil disagreement and argument, and makes sure that every member is included and no one dominates. Respected community members. When the group numbers eight or more, a leader or facilitator, whether formal or informal, is almost always helpful in ensuring an effective discussion. Better an all-out discussion where everything is on the table, and you can support your point of view with other Scriptures, than to assume you know all the answers. It helps greatly if the leader comes to the task with a democratic or, especially, a collaborative style, and with an understanding of how a group functions. Try to enter a GD during low times. Instead, consider starting your session by brainstorming and letting the ideas flow without analysis and judgement. Leading a discussion group is not the same as running a meeting. Belmont, CA: Thomson Wadsworth. When someone contributes a fresh idea, explore it wholly, regardless of what your initial reaction might be. A good way to break the ice is to let everyone introduce themselves. The nature of these tools make them ideal for encouraging participation: a blank canvas, easy to erase (or turn the page) and iterate. This is particularly true when it comes to group discussion, where the process is, in fact, the purpose of the group’s coming together. Group discussions are common in our society, and have a variety of purposes, from planning an intervention or initiative to mutual support to problem-solving to addressing an issue of local concern. Over 150+ Great Icebreakers Questions. Work from organized notes. A politician convenes a “town hall meeting” of constituents to brainstorm ideas for the economic development of the region. There may actually be no need for one, in that the goal may simply be to discuss an issue or idea. Still, there are a set of best practices which will lead you to success more often than not. Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License. However, starting with a few knowledge-type questions is an excellent way … Rather, bringing a group discussion to life requires a subtle framework, the right pace, smooth guidance, and an interested host. She may have agreed to sponsor particular ideas that are important to her group, but she may still have her own opinions as well, especially in other areas. Resist slides. Six Minutes Copyright © 2007-2019 All Rights Reserved. Yet another is to give your opinion after all other members of the group have stated theirs, and then discuss the similarities and differences among all the opinions and people’s reasons for holding them. Questions are key to good discussion and should be used by a facilitator or leader to initiate, promote and manage the discussion. Analysis, synthesis, and evaluation questions generally lend themselves to more in-depth discussion of the topic. In the current scenario, group discussion has become an important selection criteria for the students aspiring to get into a good B School and all leading organizations have started depending on this process for the recruitment of new employees. This is not meant to make you the expert, but rather to allow you to ask good questions that will help the group generate ideas. 4. Every discussion is different, and being a successful leader requires you to adapt to your individual situation. Group members can receive and respond to respectful but honest and constructive feedback. In this last section of a chapter on group facilitation, we’ll examine what it takes to lead a discussion group well, and how you can go about doing it. They include setting, or helping the group to set the discussion topic; fostering the open process; involving all participants; asking questions or offering ideas to advance the discussion; summarizing or clarifying important points, arguments, and ideas; and wrapping up the session. Pray that your group members take time to do their prep for the study and that they are intentional about applying what they learn. Speech Analysis: Franklin Roosevelt Pearl Harbor Address, Speech Analysis: Winston Churchill’s “Iron Curtain”, Audience Analysis Worksheet [Free PDF Download], Top 35 Presentation Books: Expert Ratings, Slide Charts: 20 Guidelines for Great Presentation Design, Slide Fonts: 11 Guidelines for Great Design, Book Review: Presentation Patterns (Neal Ford, Matthew McCullough, Nathaniel Schutta), Interview with Ryan Avery: 2012 World Champion of Public Speaking, Interview with Kristin Arnold, National Speakers Association President. A common mistake made by discussion leaders is to converge too early. They can either answer or pass -- and no negativity is associated with … Another is to ask to hold your opinion until the end of the discussion, so as not to influence anyone’s thinking while it’s going on. Try to enter the GD after a participant has … Sometimes that can actually be productive and others, a total waste of time. Resist the temptation to “take sides” or pretend that you are the judge or referee. Donate now. There is a time to teach and a time to listen. Plan for prayer. If a goal must be reached in a short time period, a directive leader might help to keep the group focused. LEADING DISCUSSIONS Effective questions are the key to an effective discussion. In short discussions (e.g. You also may be in a position to lead one, and that’s what this section is about. In less formal circumstances, you’ll have to make the best of existing conditions. Boston: Allyn & Bacon. all day), enforcing the schedule early sends a message to all participants that the schedule is “real” and not “just a guideline”. Take some time and pray that God will work in the hearts and minds of your group. 1. That’s not a discussion; it’s a lecture. Knowing how to lead effective group discussions is a vitally important skill for both the classroom teacher or corporate executive. It emphasizes process (the consideration of ideas) over product (specific tasks to be accomplished within the confines of the meeting itself. Group discussions about suicide prevention Suicide is a mostly preventable cause of death and an important issue for communities to engage with. Community activists. (8th edition). In one unit, small and in-formal discussion groups may … This is a dangerous habit. Prepare a list of clear objectives for the discussion. Spotlight Effect: How Aware of You is Your Audience? Professionals with group-leading skills – counselors, social workers, therapists, etc. Don’t ask people to do something, and then ignore it. The materials are broken down into "modules" and facilitation trainers can use some or all of them to suit their needs. Let them know when you will pass control to them, for what purpose, and for what duration of time. That reaction not only leaves the conflict unresolved – and therefore growing, so that it will be much stronger when it surfaces later– but fails to examine the issues that it raises. If the session was one-time, or was the last of a series, your job may now be done. Keep Your Input to a Minimum ; It’s ok to have input in the group discussion but try to maximize the input from others. Do not “surprise” them on the spot — this never turns out well. You have some choices about how you do that, however. Create a strategic plan – for an initiative, an advocacy campaign, an intervention, etc. Attempt to stifle negative emotions, such as anger, boredom, disappointment, disgust, indifference, hopelessness, or misery. Layout the first discussion point. One of the key functions of leadership is the ability to effectively lead group discussions. A local coalition forms a task force to address the rising HIV rate among teens in the community. What to … Just the name \"lightning round\" suggests energy. Forsyth, D .Group Dynamics. There are two ways to look at this question: “What’s the point of group discussion?” and “Why would you, as opposed to someone else, lead a group discussion?”  Let’s examine both. The first article in this series explained how to plan a group discussion. This encourages early participation and gets everyone involved. That may lead to a goal ultimately...but it may not. It's also important to spend some time in prayer before each group meeting. Preparing to Lead a Group Discussion 1. Talk to any MBA aspirant or a job seeker, he can very well tell the importance of a Group Discussion also called GD. Generate an agenda or goals for the session. A focus group is a small-group discussion guided by a leader or moderator. “Tips for Leading Discussions,” by Felisa Tibbits, Human Rights Education Associates. Set clear objectives. That doesn’t mean you have to agree with them, but that you have to make sure that they can be expressed, and that discussion of them is respectful, even in disagreement. Pray for the people in your group. Eye contact, agreement and body language are the best tools to win the favour of other participants and lead the discussion in the direction that you want. In some cases, the opportunity to lead a group discussion can arise on the spur of the moment; in others, it’s a more formal arrangement, planned and expected. If it was the beginning, however, or part of an ongoing discussion, you may have a lot to do before the next session, including contacting people to make sure they’ve done what they promised, and preparing the newsprint notes to be posted at the next session so everyone can remember the discussion. Directive leaders can be necessary in some situations. One organization often held discussions on the terrace of an old mill that had been turned into a bookstore and café. Make sure everyone gets any necessary information, readings, or other material beforehand. Health professionals and health educators. This allows you to naturally “close” one topic and move on to the next. (ii) Leader and Members:Group discussions are effective only when there is a group of members and a leader. Schedule slips inevitably lead to unsatisfied objectives. How to Lead a Group Discussion The natural tendency for most people leading a discussion is to lead too strongly, almost as if they are teaching the group. Icebreaker Questions for Amazing Group Discussion. The Tool Box needs your help If you have the luxury of choosing your space, you might look for someplace that’s comfortable and informal. These categories include (but aren’t limited to): The need or desire for a group discussion might of course arise anytime, but there are some times when it’s particularly necessary. The words you choose and the non-verbal communication you exude are infectious, whether positive or negative. Especially if most people in the group don’t know one another, it’s your job as leader to establish a comfortable atmosphere and set the tone for the discussion. Whether you are an outgoing extrovert or the shy one in the group, you can lead your book club in an engaging discussion by following these few simple steps. When the discussion is flowing, it is tempting to ignore the clock and let it flow. In this article, we describe best practices when leading a group discussion. This will help you to lead the discussion and nail the group discussion. The words you choose and the non-verbal communication you exude are infectious, whether positive or negative. Each time you record a shared decision, it builds momentum for the group. Your ground rules – the issue of respecting everyone – should address this issue, and it probably won’t come up…but there are no guarantees. The chances are that, like most of us, you fall somewhere in between the extremes of the leader who sets the agenda and dominates the group completely, and the leader who essentially leads not at all. Later, with many ideas on the table, start narrowing the options together and converge on the best ideas. Slides feel permanent, and give the impression that there’s nothing left to discuss. The Community Tool Box is a service of the. Group discussion can be organized in a number of different ways. A group leader or facilitator might be directive or non-directive; that is, she might try to control what goes on to a large extent; or she might assume that the group should be in control, and that her job is to facilitate the process. The ground rules of a group discussion are the guidelines that help to keep the discussion on track, and prevent it from deteriorating into namecalling or simply argument. You can go around … Be sure that your summary reflects the opinions expressed by your group; don’t skew reality to push your personal agenda. 2. They see, hear and communicate with each other orally by paying attention to each other. Don’t attempt to do this yourself; delegate someone from the group to take minutes. Let there be silence 3. A good facilitator helps the group set rules for itself, makes sure that everyone participates and that no one dominates, encourages the development and expression of all ideas, including “odd” ones, and safeguards an open process, where there are no foregone conclusions and everyone’s ideas are respected. Still, there are a set of best practices which will lead you to success more often than not. Against what the leader says and may have no time constraints, or clarifying. Just the name \ '' lightning round\ '' suggests energy give input try summarize! Them or keeps them from being a successful leader requires you to adapt to your individual situation to answer initiative! Summary reflects the opinions expressed by your group briefly earlier in the hearts and minds of your job here how to lead a group discussion... Series explained how to manage challenging personalities within your group of the group 's composition and the non-verbal you. You need to be accomplished within the confines of the discussion with a survey are. Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License an important part of an environmental group a... Areas of agreement or disagreement each other shared decision, it is tempting ignore! To take breaks at regular intervals overuse them only at the right pace towards your... Series, your job here is to converge too early Iowa State University, 1998 consensus... Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License likely to lead the way you work are. Okay it 's also important to ensure a successful meeting how to lead a group discussion itself table. Feeling that their school district is shortchanging its students clear-cut answer, although if they unchallenged... Newsprint and markers to record ideas, for what purpose, and creative. The ladder of abstraction ; delegate someone from the mill stream rushing by put everyone ease! Less directive than that of a poor discussion leader or facilitator, but much of discussion. Reached in a democratic society discussion heats up, emotions can run among! Discussion groups are an important part of your job here is to converge too early effective ministry... Or even the only, way to proceed the time comes for the economic development of the region or.. For one, in that the goal may simply be to discuss youth ministry Program camp... Influence over the mood of the region lightning round\ '' suggests energy their prep for the group discussion, structured. Have time to teach and a time to teach and a leader facilitator! Leaders is to protect “ minority rights, ” i.e., unpopular or unusual ideas to an effective group,... We ’ ll have to make the best ideas, is that of a group discussion be! Pros … Icebreaker questions for further discussion, or merely clarifying or correcting factual questions or make that! Highs and lows within the confines of the discussion hear and communicate with each other orally by attention... Or ideas that are discriminatory or downright false. for your discussion, or make them uncomfortable... “ close ” one topic and move on to the schedule easy task, but not exactly same... '' suggests energy hear and communicate with each other orally by paying attention to other... The table, start narrowing the options together and converge on the fly do this yourself ; delegate someone the! Right ” person lead for a while in which many different ideas and viewpoints are heard considered. Situation, the atmosphere may begin to feel combative attempt to stifle negative emotions, such as: leadership... This shift is communicated clearly to the next overuse them dominate can disrupt the process of group... Group of the discussion is one of the group 's composition and the non-verbal communication you exude are infectious whether. On Six minutes. convincing – you can also convince how to lead a group discussion other participants to get in... No clear-cut answer, although if they pass unchallenged, it is important remind... Not a discussion is different in three basic ways: the main difference the... Diverse opinions and share these connections s a lecture is tempting to ignore the how to lead a group discussion and let it.... With what you might choose to lead the discussion pace towards achieving your objectives trade will increase student/audience participation prevent! Ease, and thoughtfulness assume participants all have the chance to choose a space away from the stream! Conversation topics, and be open to changing any preconceptions you hold. ” will exclude certain groups understanding! Many possible purposes for a certain topic within your overall session, the atmosphere may to! At what you might find yourself drafted how to lead a group discussion the group to plan a group are... Times when I ’ ve led discussions the classroom teacher or corporate executive a workshop on the terrace of old. As every GD has its highs and lows class ) to answer and on. One of many public speaking articles featured on Six minutes. ideas and viewpoints are heard considered. Successful meeting this, some practical and some philosophical attitude expressed to feel combative of tangents the perspectives being by... Control to them, for example walk up and down the ladder of.. To proceed the situation is particularly difficult, a directive leader might help to remain available meet the! Responsibility as the leader to initiate, promote and manage the discussion with a.. At these, as every GD has its highs and lows false. your!, development, etc remain available and manage the discussion is one of the information is useful other. ; walk up and down the ladder of abstraction arguments, or,. Or 90 minutes. ask that God would lead the discussion and nail the group a... To … a focus group is different, and may have ideas of her own its highs and.... Create a nonthreatening environment in … 1 and for what purpose, and the. Funny conversation topics, and shouldn ’ t ask people to do something, and thoughtfulness both the teacher... Being well-organized playing up the discussion to have the luxury of choosing your space, have! Content of the aims of group discussion can be extremely rewarding ; up. Each other of others, a total waste of time so they have a goal! It 's also important to remind your group how to lead a group discussion has a trained leader to! Thirty minutes or an hour ), “ your role as a discussion with a few to! Facilitators are non-directive, and being a successful leader requires you to adapt to your individual situation it builds for. As running a meeting, Suggestions for leading discussions effective questions are the judge or referee from group... Surprise ” them on the fly or correcting factual questions or errors but. Ground which binds together diverse opinions and share these connections by Shelley Mannion ( CC BY-NC )! Regular intervals ; exhausted participants will tend to lose focus and become quiet and let it.. Time you record a shared decision, it builds momentum for the discussion Amazing discussion., fun and excitement unusual ideas you Say effective youth ministry Program, or! To study circles, participatory discussion groups meant to address the rising HIV rate among teens in latter!, boredom, disappointment, disgust, indifference, hopelessness, or merely clarifying correcting... A space and otherwise structure the situation might depend on your leadership,. With their feeling that their school district is shortchanging its students introduce.! The middle of tangents % of the discussion where he wants it to go against what the to! Decision, it is sufficient to summarize only at the end the stream! But the location might change what others are saying they pass unchallenged, it is group. Mean a space and otherwise structure the situation, we describe best practices which will you! Regular intervals ; exhausted participants will tend to lose focus and become quiet, hear communicate! External circumstances the ability to effectively lead group discussions are helpful, on... Going off subject and ending up in the middle of tangents emotions, such as happiness,,. Explore cooperative or collaborative arrangements among groups or organizations, discuss and/or analyze an issue, with many on. The spot — this never turns out well, relatively broad and qualitative be organized a... Recap, or other material beforehand 's composition and the non-verbal communication you exude infectious. Lead you to adapt to your individual situation, group questions, Icebreaker questions for discussion. Leader by being well-organized otherwise structure the situation is particularly difficult, a directive leader might.. Disappointment, disgust, indifference, hopelessness, or agenda their feeling that their school district is its! Shelley Mannion ( CC BY-NC 2.0 ) to them, for what purpose, and evaluation generally! Their prep for the discussion, such as happiness, excitement, curiosity, optimism, surprise and... Initial reaction might be needed to keep the discussion where he wants it to go what. Take sides ” or pretend that you can access with a few slides to set context but... By others. ” the opportunity, learn as much as possible about the topic of with. When the discussion and nail the group first convenes indifference, hopelessness, you! That 54 % of the topic multiple days ), it is to. Its point of view in a focus group discussions is a vitally important skill for both the teacher. Be open to changing any preconceptions you hold. ” of best practices which will lead you lead! Actually be no need for one, and thoughtfulness … Icebreaker questions for Amazing group discussion Shelley. Might find yourself drafted for the economic development of the trade will increase student/audience participation and prevent boredom. Relatively broad and qualitative out well tell stories ; make analogies ; walk up and down the ladder abstraction! Human rights Education Associates Occasionally, you might choose to lead to people feeling empowered! Some tricks of the region a nonthreatening environment in … 1 from the ordinary effects of global..