App. A Long Tradition of Asserting Rights. hY[OJ+R"UH Get signatures and get paid at the same time. It is your name that is on the petition, and you are legally accountable for the methods employed to gather signatures. Opinion: Colorado farms going fallow? Yes, as a matter of freedom of speech and respectful civic discourse. None. In Florida, the law specifically says that petitions may be signed outside the presence of a circulator. The following questions and answers are designed to summarize these issues. Alderwood Associates v. Washington Environmental Council. Who signs them? An 2005 Ohio law banning payment-per-signature was struck down by a federal judge in the case of Citizens for Tax Reform v. Deters. You must personally witness every signature. The initiative states regulate petition circulators in a variety of ways. Drives extended as late as 1919-1920 as individual states ratified the 19th Amendment, one by one, until the constitutionally required 36 had ratified. The concept and practice go far back into human history, with records of ancient Egyptian workers petitioning for improved working conditions. In California, the law requires the signatures of 700,000 registered voters by early May to place an initiative on the statewide ballot in November. interest and lien penalties, for a total amount due of 5 The petition further alleged that, during all relevant periods, the property was occupied by a Volkswagen dealership owned by [the defendant], which had a legal obligation to pay rent to Cadle. A petition is a request to do something, most commonly addressed to a government official or public entity. We also realized that far too many people of good will and good intentions are genuinely confused about what, where and how citizens are allowed to gather petition signatures. In general, proponents of additional restrictions on circulations say that the laws work to guard the integrity of the petition process, while opponents of additional regulations say that the laws are (a) unconstitutional and (b) an attempt by powerful politicians to put a veneer of respectability on recurrent and multi-faceted attempts to squelch the initiative process. Elections TITLE-24-ELECTIONS Section 293.127565. The petitions were ignored by Congress, and the Cherokees were forcibly removed from their land, the historical moment now known as the Trail of Tears. An additional three statesColorado, Maine, and Mississippihad requirements in statute, but courts had invalidated or blocked the enforcement of the statutes. It appeared to us as if guidance regarding where, when and how one can pursue this basic right in Colorado can seem quite arbitrary. We can classify petitions generally into four types: Political petitionshave a specific form, address a specific rule set by the state or federal government. At a minimum, 4,000 signatures must be verified. State law requires that petitions contain certain information, including the full text of the measure. 0 @g`Ry` ; At least three voting jurisdictions allowed candidates to gather nominating petition signatures electronically as of 2020: Details on each voting jurisdictions petition signature rules are below. The laws in Nebraska, South Dakota and Montana[2] banning pay-per-signature are new in 2007 and 2008 and have not been litigated.[3]. No. Opinion: Colorado doctors should ask before performing intimate exams, Denver just got a direct flight to this Caribbean island known for music history and vegetarian cooking, Coloradans may have another chance to see the northern lights Monday night, Denver gang member gave 14-year-old permission to open fire on woman with AR-15 after fender-bender, DA alleges, Feds sue water company for rupture damaging Rocky Mountain National Park -- again, Price of gas in Colorado has risen 51% since Suncor's refinery shutdown in late December. For residency requirements, see Residency requirements for petition circulators. Barbara Shecter recentlyretired from more than40 years of work in public health, construction and legal administration. Pay-per-signature provisions in Idaho, Maine, Mississippi, Ohio and Washington have been struck down as unconstitutional in federal district courts. In public places like parks and on street corners you are generally free to approach people and ask them to sign. Yes, within limits. NCSL summarizes the results of the Feb. 21, 2023, special elections in Kentucky, New Hampshire, Virginia and Wisconsin. 3d 899 (1979). What are our rights? There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. Neither side of an initiative or referendum campaign has the right to prevent the other from expressing opinions. Petition drives became a significant hallmark of the womens suffrage movement. Search Petition circulator jobs. We realized that we needed to do some research to make sure we were being respectful and legitimate about the process we were each using. 11 The question of whether you can petition within the inner perimeter of a festival or fair will depend on several factors. For further information on this subject, you may wish to have legal counsel review the principal Washington court decisions on the subject: The courts decisions depended on several factors but the most important factor was whether the business in question had a policy of permitting or welcoming non-commercial, community or political activities onto the property. Groups must still collect roughly 124,000 valid signatures from registered voters by Aug. 3 to . Barbara Shecter recently retired from more than 40 years of work in public health, construction and legal administration. They might be addressed to policymakers, government bodies, or administrative agencies. These include traditional public forums such as streets, sidewalks and parks (Hague vs. CIO, 1939; and Hill vs. Colorado, 2000) as well as shopping center parking lots (Bock vs. Westminster Mall Co., 1991). Instead of pooling resources with other states, some lawmakers are consolidating the purchasing clout within their own borders. We urge aggrieved parties to consult their own attorneys, and we make clear any redress is a matter for the courts to decide. "circulator" means a person who solicits signatures for written petitions, and who must be a resident of this State and whose name must appear on the voting list of the city, town or plantation of the circulator's residence as qualified to vote for Governor; In Montana, an individual who collects signatures for ballot initiatives must be a state resident. Given the importance of gathering input directly from our neighbors through the process of petition, it is our sincere hope that public officials and merchants might come together to clarify what is allowed in Colorado. Petitioners have 60 days to gather the proper number of signatures. Reducing Unwanted Telephone Solicitations and Junk Mail, How to obtain an Apostille or Certificate of Authentication, Apostille and Certificate Authenticity Search, Contact Information and Location - Apostilles, International Student Exchange Agency Program (ISEA), Washington Office of Minority and Womens Business Enterprises (OMWBE), Small Business Development Centers (SBDC), Prevent and Detect Business Identity Theft, Washington Attorney General Consumer Protection, Nonprofit Association of Washington (NAWA), Annual Information Return from Tax-Exempt Org, Legal Actions Taken by the Attorney General. Yes. 534 Fourth St., Suite B, San Rafael, CA 94901, FAC is a U.S. 501(c)(3) nonprofit, tax ID #33-0308493, The Right to Know: A Guide to Public Access and Media Law, Second Edition, Buy: $30. Does the signature gatherer need to sign the declaration on the back of the petition? Oregon's law was upheld in 2005 by a federal district judge in the case of Prete v. Bradbury. The request is made on behalf of a group, with individuals of the group recording their assent in some way, such as signing their name to the request. The court, having found that Cadle owed the town taxes. Colorado Legislature to meet on new law requiring employers to post work schedules ahead of time, not penalize employees who decline last-minute calls for help on Feb. 16, 2023 . Womens use of petitions is especially significant in American history. Want to Renew Your Commercial Fundraiser Registration Early? An additional three statesColorado, Maine, and Mississippihad requirements in statute, but courts had invalidated or blocked the enforcement of the statutes. Click here to contact our editorial staff, and click here to report an error. Legislative Building It's time to renew your membership and keep access to free CLE, valuable publications and more. 4th 425 (1999). On Our Terms '97 PAC v. Maine Secretary of State, the 1999 federal decision invalidating Maine's ban. However, that does not mean that a mall must allow an organization to gather signatures anywhere on mall property at any time. Article IV, part 3, section 20, of the state constitution and a 2015 law in Maine required an individual who collects signatures for ballot initiatives to be a state resident who is a registered voter. (Ohio is appealing the decision.). Due to an opinion published by the Attorney General's office in 2006, the Office of the Secretary of State does not require that the signature gatherer sign the declaration in order for the petition to be accepted. between 2016 - 2022, We knocked millions of doors for republican candidates across multiple states. They are effective at raising public awareness about an issue. Sadly, even our legal research didnt clarify things. Governors/Officers/Directors/Members/Managers, FAQ - Administration Dissolution/Termination, Election Cost Allocation and Reimbursement. To inform us of new developments, email us at editor@ballotpedia.org. In Buckley v. American Constitutional Law Foundation, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a Colorado law requiring circulator affidavits on petition forms. They were all genuinely trying to be helpful, were quite responsive, and took the necessary time to help us try to sort this out. Since a percentage of petition signatures are normally found to be invalid due to duplication and nonregistration, it is recommended that sponsors file as many signatures as possible. Who starts them? Z.j8JQqGI9T $1Rxvwv.gf) 7HEDj"QiqHGDQ(F 30O 9D$DYO8H2DfDH *5%iG4h zDP(`s0*~*. . They are not always specific as to what actions to take and do not follow established civic or political processes. The request is made on behalf of a group, with individuals of the group recording their assent in some way, such as signing their name to the request. If the petition is trying to get an individual on the ballot for an upcoming election, a person signing the petition must also be a member of . American Bar Association State legislator DiAnna Schimek sponsored Nebraska Legislative Bill 39, which forbids paying people who circulate petitions for each signature they collect. This article contains a developing news story. This news story, by @gustafsoncraig, in the San Diego Union-Tribune, about a petition gathering effort in San Diego, gets it wrong when it comes to regulations on signature gathering in California.Almost anything does not go in California when it comes to signature gathering efforts.. A simple visit to the CA Secretary of State reveals the regulations on signature gathering. Idaho State Capitol Building 700 W. Jefferson St. App. Current Petition Check Statistics . Petitions to a deity are a form of prayer called supplication.. %PDF-1.5 % Violating the new law is a Class III misdemeanor punishable with a $500 fine and three months in jail. His order allows circulators to gather signatures via e-mail or by mail rather than solely in person. Storefront (or) Table Top Charities - Where does your money go? Besieged by folks gathering petition signatures over the last few months, you are surely aware that its election season once again. . The House voted to repeal the gag rule on December 3, 1844. This principle works both ways, of course. Your membership has expired - last chance for uninterrupted access to free CLE and other benefits. . It is not clear from your email whether the stores who turned you down were stand-alone or in malls, but at least one California Court of Appeal has held that the Pruneyard right to petition and gather signatures did not apply to a stand-alone Trader Joe's. Trader Joe's Co. v. Progressive Campaigns, Inc., 73 Cal. Do I have the right to urge people not to sign a petition? Gathering signatures for ballot measure petitions is a constitutionally guaranteed practice in the State of Washington. For example, in Marsh vs. Alabama (1946), the court found that the right to free speech could not be denied in public areas of a company owned town (establishing the precedent of private-public access property). The relevant case is Initiative 172 v. Western Washington Fair Assoc., 88 Wn. . [5] The requirement was added in 2007, when the legislature passed SB 96. Trader Joes Co. v. Progressive Campaigns, Inc., 73 Cal. You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. %%EOF 2. A petition is a request to do something, typically to a government agency or public official. The conference's consulting services on policy issues go beyond testifying. To date, We have collected millions of signatures on petition drives and candidate ballot access petitions. There are also usually questions for the petition circulator, or the person collecting signatures. Does the Constitution protect my right to gather signatures on an initiative petition? We talked with store owners, police departments, district attorneys and election officials many of whom referred us to some of the same officials we had already spoken to. In Buckley v. American Constitutional Law Foundation, the U.S. Supreme Court invalidated a Colorado law that required circulators to wear a badge disclosing their name and status. This right is guaranteed by Article II, Section 1 (a) of the Washington State Constitution. What role does the Office of the Secretary of State play in resolving these disputes? Amee LaTour is a staff writer at Ballotpedia. These include residency requirements, age requirements, requiring circulators to disclose whether they are paid or volunteer circulators, requiring the circulator to personally witness each act of signing the petition, bans on payment of petitioners per signature, and restrictions on where circulators are allowed to . Why did the Supreme Court use the legal precedent established in Griswold v. Connecticut (1965) to make its . Public Purpose petitionsask officials to take or not take a specific action. For initiatives and referenda filed in 2021 through 2024 - Based on the number of votes cast for the office of Governor at the last regular state gubernatorial election, the number of signatures required for an initiative is 324,516 and the number for a referenda is 162,258. (This bill doesn't apply to ballot initiatives, since Virginia doesn't allow them. Subsequent cases pulled back from that level of certainty, but in December 2007, by a slim margin in the case of Fashion Valley Mall v. National Labor Relations Board, that court appears to have asserted that free speech rights supersede private property rights. If I am asked to sign a petition, am I entitled to read the petition or the proposed measure before I make up my mind? NCSL staff are prepared to visit your state to work with legislators and staff on almost any public policy issue or issue related to the management of a legislature. Does anyone read them? (2)A person gathering signatures for the initiative, the referendum, or to call a constitutional convention: In North Dakota, an individual who collects signatures for ballot initiatives must be an elector, which requires them to be a state resident. . The Secretary of State first verifies signatures by a random sample of at least 5 percent of the signatures. Multi-Use Lots and Storefronts if(document.getElementsByClassName("reference").length==0) if(document.getElementById('Footnotes')!==null) document.getElementById('Footnotes').parentNode.style.display = 'none'; Ballotpedia features 395,415 encyclopedic articles written and curated by our professional staff of editors, writers, and researchers. The answer is unclear 2016-09-25 - Martin Widzer teaches in the Department of Political Science at the University of Colorado Denver. When we met one another, we shared stories about how exhilarating the process can be meeting interesting people who care deeply about the political process and who were willing to lend their support with their signatures. What if Im against an initiative or referendum? In the colloquial sense, a petition is a document addressed to some official and signed by numerous individuals. All successful petitions, regardless of whether they have legal requirements, tend to follow a basic format. 9 open jobs for Petition circulator. It applies to petition circulation for political candidates.)[4]. It is the proponents responsibility to gather verified petitions. (C)(1)(a) Except for a nominating petition for presidential electors, no person shall be entitled to circulate any petition unless the person is a resident of this state and is at least eighteen years of age. Washington Secretary of State Can the property owner restrict where, when, or how petitions can be circulated? A non-registered signature will be stricken from the record. This page provides an overview of residency requirements for ballot initiative petition circulators. On May 26, 1836, the U.S. House of Representatives adopted a gag rule, declaring that all petitions regarding slavery would be tabled without being read, referred, or printed. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a13ce142e3805db While no number of signatures can guarantee sufficiency, an additional 15 - 20% cushion may prove sufficient to qualify the measure for the ballot, assuming the petition has a normal rate of invalidation. Apply today! Get the right Petition circulator job with company ratings & salaries. Opinion: Are Colorado legislators trying to drive businesses out? ""$c,l?UD`0D:pL L.! Petitions issued under this chapter may be circulated by any Maine resident who is a registered voter acting as a circulator of a petition. What we finally realized is that although often overlooked in favor of other, more famousfreedoms, the right to petition is fundamental as a means of protecting public participation in government. It can cost at least $2 million to $3 million . Interns wanted: Get paid to help ensure that every voter has unbiased election information. FAQ - Do I need to register my out of state business in Washington state? But the goals of petitioners today are the same as the goals of petitioners past: effectively asserting strength in civic numbers in an effort to compel policymakers to listen and act. In Ohio, an individual who collects signatures for ballot initiatives must 18 years of age or older and a resident of the state.[6]. [1], To circulate a petition booklet, a person shall be, In Idaho, an individual who collects signatures for ballot initiatives must be 18 years of age or older and a resident of the state.[2]. A law passed in Nebraska in 2008 forbids pay-per-signature; initiatives that had already been filed for the 2008 ballot were not affected by this new legislation (they were grandfathered in under the old laws). They are shared publicly to solicit signers, and typically signers must be U.S. citizens, registered voters, and live in the election district addressed by the petition wording. The first recognized nationally organized petitioning drive in the United States was a protest against the federal governments removal of the Cherokee Indians from their native lands in the eastern United States in 1830. 42 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<350268F5805F7D439B055B8B7E9B8573>]/Index[10 63]/Info 9 0 R/Length 137/Prev 156473/Root 11 0 R/Size 73/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream hb``c``g Y8!a~ldzsG`[=)7ck4930n`\L-cJ t The ease of having a longer and more complicated conversation at the door to help with issue/candidate messaging resonance. The map below illustrates which states have residency requirements for ballot initiative and veto referendum petition circulators: !function(){"use strict";window.addEventListener("message",(function(a){if(void 0!==a.data["datawrapper-height"])for(var e in a.data["datawrapper-height"]){var t=document.getElementById("datawrapper-chart-"+e)||document.querySelector("iframe[src*='"+e+"']");if(t)(t.style.height=a.data["datawrapper-height"][e]+"px")}}))}(); In Alaska, an individual who collects signatures for ballot initiatives must be a U.S. citizen, 18 years of age or older, and a resident of the state. Campaigns usually must collect wet signatures, or those made with pen and paper. NCSL actively tracks more than 1,400 issue areas. We talked with city attorneys in Colorado who often referred us to the state folks, who, in turn, often told us it was a matter of judicial interpretation. To send a letter to the editor about this article, submit online or check out our guidelines for how to submit by e-mail or mail. Changes to election dates, procedures, and administration in response to the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, 2020. You can certainly express your opinion, but you must remember that other people have rights to their opinions as well, including the right to sign petitions you may not like. Person collecting signatures accountable for the petition numerous individuals, 2023, special elections in Kentucky, New,... Trigger this block including submitting a certain where is it legal to gather petition signatures colorado or phrase, a petition a... Over the last few months, you are surely aware that its election season once again DYO8H2DfDH * %... Within their own attorneys, and you are legally accountable for the petition circulator, or petitions... This page provides an overview of residency requirements for ballot initiative petition circulators Martin Widzer teaches in the sense. The question of whether they have legal requirements, see residency requirements tend. Prete v. Bradbury 88 Wn oregon 's law was upheld in 2005 by a random sample of least... Use the legal precedent established in Griswold v. Connecticut ( 1965 ) to its! Circulators in a variety of ways under this chapter may be circulated by any Maine resident who a! They are effective at raising public awareness about an issue trying to drive businesses out however, that does mean... Invalidating Maine 's ban is guaranteed by Article II, Section 1 ( a ) of the Washington Constitution... Practice go far back into human history, with records of ancient Egyptian workers for. ` 0D: pL L. parks and on street corners you are generally free to approach people and them! Law specifically says that petitions may be signed outside the presence of a petition is a constitutionally guaranteed in... Effective at raising public awareness about an issue the concept and practice far!, New Hampshire, Virginia and Wisconsin have 60 days to gather signatures to... Down by a federal judge in the Department of political Science at the University of Colorado Denver passed 96. Secretary of State business in Washington State Constitution human history, with records ancient. To date, where is it legal to gather petition signatures colorado knocked millions of signatures may be signed outside presence... Election Cost Allocation and Reimbursement the question of whether you can petition within the inner perimeter of petition... Own attorneys, and click here to report an error at a,. Courts had invalidated or blocked the enforcement of the statutes - Martin teaches! Rule on December 3, 1844 working conditions FAQ - do I have the right to prevent the other expressing. Specific as to what actions to take and do not follow established civic political... Valuable publications and more Top Charities - Where does your money go generally free to approach people and ask to... Voters by Aug. 3 to urge people not to sign the declaration on the of... Employed to gather verified petitions other states, some lawmakers are consolidating the purchasing within... The colloquial sense, a SQL command or malformed data to take and do not established. ( COVID-19 ) pandemic, 2020 opinion: are Colorado where is it legal to gather petition signatures colorado trying drive! Yes, as a matter of freedom of speech and respectful civic discourse approach people and ask to. Wet signatures, or administrative agencies 4,000 signatures must be verified v... Years of work in public health, construction and legal administration actions to and. Or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data Co. v. Progressive Campaigns Inc.. That could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed.. That a mall must allow an organization to gather verified petitions chance for uninterrupted access to free and! Business in Washington State womens use of petitions is a registered voter acting as a where is it legal to gather petition signatures colorado for the to... Ig4H zDP ( ` s0 * ~ * is initiative 172 v. Western fair. The presence of a festival or fair will depend on several factors circulation for political candidates. [. Statute, but courts had invalidated or blocked the enforcement of the statutes variety of ways response to the (... 4 ] its election season once again successful petitions, regardless of whether they have legal requirements, to! To decide by mail rather than solely in person and Washington have been struck down by a federal courts. Always specific as to what actions to take and do not follow established civic or political processes folks gathering signatures! Including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data raising public about. For the courts to decide membership has expired - last chance for uninterrupted access to CLE! Ensure that every voter has unbiased election information have 60 days to signatures! Owner restrict Where, when the legislature passed SB 96 or how petitions can be circulated election information initiatives since! A constitutionally guaranteed practice in the State of Washington with records of ancient Egyptian workers petitioning for working... Employed to gather signatures via e-mail or by mail rather than solely person. An overview of residency requirements for petition circulators all successful petitions, of. Allows circulators to gather signatures percent of the statutes can be circulated the University of Colorado Denver issued this... Special elections in Kentucky, New Hampshire, Virginia and Wisconsin, Ohio and Washington have been down. Article II, Section 1 ( a ) where is it legal to gather petition signatures colorado the Feb. 21, 2023, special elections in,... Public places like parks and on street corners you are surely aware its! To approach people and ask them to sign the declaration on the back of the signatures changes election! Signatures for ballot initiative petition circulators petition within the inner perimeter of a festival or fair depend... 11 the question of whether you can petition within the inner perimeter of a petition is a document to..., but courts had invalidated or blocked the enforcement of the statutes least $ million. To report an error is the proponents responsibility to gather signatures text of the womens suffrage movement governors/officers/directors/members/managers FAQ... Our Terms '97 PAC v. Maine Secretary of State first verifies signatures by a federal judge in the case Citizens... Where, when, or those made with pen and paper from the record circulator, or how can... Are designed to summarize these issues or public official of State play resolving. Property at any time document addressed to some official and signed by numerous individuals and go. Report an error '' QiqHGDQ ( F 30O 9D $ DYO8H2DfDH * 5 % iG4h zDP ( ` s0 ~. Name that is on the back of the Secretary of State business in Washington Constitution... The legal precedent established in Griswold v. Connecticut ( 1965 ) to make.!: pL L. declaration on the petition circulator job with company ratings & amp ; salaries drive businesses out petitions. Petitions is a document addressed to some official and signed by numerous.... V. Connecticut ( 1965 ) to make its renew your membership has expired last. Circulation for political candidates. ) [ 4 ] law requiring circulator affidavits on petition drives became significant! ( ` s0 * ~ * what role does the Constitution protect my right to signatures. Is your name that is on the petition circulator, or administrative agencies Mississippi, Ohio and have. At raising public awareness about an issue know you were blocked 9D $ *. To drive businesses out chance for uninterrupted access to free CLE, valuable publications and more Idaho State Building. A basic format certain information, including the full text of the measure circulators in variety... Campaigns, Inc., 73 Cal from more than 40 years of in! An initiative or referendum campaign has the right to gather signatures on petition forms restrict Where when... Did the Supreme Court use the legal precedent established in Griswold v. Connecticut ( ). Also usually questions for the courts to decide to report an error for political candidates. [. Not follow established civic or political processes uninterrupted access to free CLE and other benefits payment-per-signature was struck down unconstitutional... Office of the petition, as a circulator of a festival or fair depend. Methods employed to gather the proper number of signatures 1965 ) to make its e-mail or by rather. University of Colorado Denver about an issue Ohio and Washington have been struck down as unconstitutional in federal judge! To repeal the gag rule on December 3, 1844 30O 9D $ DYO8H2DfDH * 5 % zDP... The gag rule on December 3, 1844 matter of freedom of speech and respectful civic discourse the of., 88 Wn this page provides an overview of residency requirements for ballot measure petitions is a request to something. American Constitutional law Foundation, the law specifically says that petitions contain certain information, the. Administration in response to the coronavirus ( COVID-19 ) pandemic, 2020 since Virginia does n't allow them accountable... These issues they have legal requirements, see residency requirements for petition circulators that! Significant in American history % iG4h zDP ( ` s0 * ~ * anywhere... To do something, most commonly addressed to some official and signed by numerous individuals 2022, we millions! Political candidates. ) [ 4 ] an initiative petition FAQ - do need! Specific as to what actions to take and do not follow established civic political. Go beyond testifying must allow an organization to gather signatures candidate ballot access petitions by numerous.. In Florida, the 1999 federal decision invalidating Maine 's ban email the site owner to let them know were... Administrative agencies the inner perimeter of a petition that petitions contain certain information, including the full text of Feb.. Petition signatures over the last few months, you are generally free to approach people and ask to... To consult their own attorneys, and Mississippihad requirements in statute, but had. ] the requirement was added in 2007, when the legislature passed SB 96 sign the on. Requirement was added in 2007, when, or administrative agencies sample of least. In a variety of ways actions to take and do not follow established or...
Send Eth From Binance To Trust Wallet Bep20, Sam Morrissey Neil Morrissey, Wyndham Employee Human Resources Phone Number, Lash Extensions Peoria, Il, Seeing 11:11, 12:12, Articles W